Act 4 questions
Post your questions that you are asking over our reading of Act 4. Make sure to answer other's questions and clarify or use examples to support what you are saying.
posted by annes @ 9:39 AM
Smith's 9th Honors Class Blog
Thoughts, observations, comments, and concerns regarding our readings and classroom discussions.
Contributors
- elyseh
- Kjerstinl
- Adriana
- Karl Fisch
- HarryPotterFreak(danh)
- shaunam
- Unknown
- Connor DUCETIME
- AnnaD
- annes
- Alex_Manning
- Anoel
- Mphair
- jbarry
- Kim C. 2010
- Spencer Z
- Tom
- bawachmu
- Hannah J
- KendraS2009
- KariB
- maddyg
- emilya
- Shelbyb-dad
- sarahc
- LindsayS
- briang
- krump
- Alexaaaaa
- Dan
- Declan "Danger"
- tanal
- adamb
- Lisa Madsen Crellin
- endsleye
- TyC
- Shelby B.
- Unknown
- EmilyLu
- Unknown
- saram
- Aylar
- EmilyH
- Laurab
- hannahs
- alexd
- Phillip
- zachf
- michelleg
- chelseah
- lindsey c
- KathrynT
- Kaity
- Shelbyb-mom
- paigen
Previous Posts
- LOF question ch 7-8 p.2
- Act 3 Questions
- LOF question period 2
- Act 2 questions continued...
- Evil...
- Phony Faces
- Macbeth Act One Powerful Questions
- Lord of the Flies ch.1
- Trust...To trust or not to trust, that is the ques...
- Learning and Grades the Magical Connection
26 Comments:
I actually don't really know what they were doing besides giving him confidence. I think they were trying to get him to do things they want him to do. They want to confuse him. What I want to know is what the tree in the third apparitions hand could be a symbol for?
Ok. My first question. At the beginning of scene 2 when it sets up the scene and gives a brief overview of the scene, it says that both Macduff's wife and son were killed in the scene. But when we got to the end, only the son was killed right? Where was Macduff when all this happened or does it not matter? He was killed though, right? Or was that just a lie told? Why exactly did Macbeth want Macduff's family to be killed?
Kjerstinl,
I was very confused about that too. I think that if you read scene three your question as to whether or not Macbeth is alive is answered. (I can't answer this one in case someone didn't read it yet.)
I think that the presence of Macduff does matter as refrenced in scene three. Going off of what we know in just scene two, I believe that the lack of Macduff goes back to gender roles. I think that Macduff is the protector of Lady Macduff and her son. Without him she seems more vunerable.
As for whether LAdy Macduff is alive that agin is refrenced in scene three. Going off just scene two, notice that she was followed out by murders.
I was reading additional commentary on Macbeth, and it said that Macbteh really doesn't have motive for killing the son of Macduff and possibly Lady Macduff. My interpretation of this it that in a sense Macbteh is addicted to murder. Once he murders one person he has to murder another and another and another, and he can't seem to get out it.
I hope this helps.
Questins: Why are the witches chanting at the beinging of the Act and why are they putting all these different ingredients into a cauldren?
I am really confused from when Macduff and Malcolm are talkig? What is Malcolm trying to get at?
I like this quote "The night is long that never finds the day"
What do you think that it means. I have my own ideas but I was wondering what you think.
I am a little bit confused,does Lady Macbeth have a son? If that is not her son then who is it?
erinl- For your first question, I think that the witches are chanting because maybe that is what makes the potion work or let them connect to other spirits. But, I am not sure why they are putting certain things into the potion... good question!
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Shauna M. remember there is a Ldy Macduff is that what you're talking about?
Erin L. I agree with Shauna M. that it has to do with bringing out the spirits, but also that I think that it also is to maybe bring out a stronger feeling maybe of more confusion or maybe just to make you think I'm not sure.
Kjerstin well i think only Lady Macduff was killed in that scene and Macduff fled to england.
also to add onto shelby's answer, i think the witches were making the potion to bring out the spirits, but also to help them convince Macbeth that evrything he is doing is perfect and trying to make him feel really confident so that they can help him take a great fall.
I was a little confused when about the apparitonists. Were they just like ghosts that macbeth was seeing or what??
Aleea, Ross lied to Macduff earlier in the scene because he couldn't stand to share the grief of the murders, but told him about them later. I think Siward is the English general who would lead the attack against Scotland in order to liberate it from Macbeth's rule.
Now I have a question: Why is Macduff testing Malcolm? Is it to determine whether he can trust him or to make him angry enough to want to go overthrow Macbeth? I also don't understand why Malcolm was doubting himself so much. He kept talking about how he was unfit to rule because of his evilness. It would be great if someone would explain this part to me.
For anyone who is confused about the witches, I think that they are just doing stuff that witches do. Their leader comes right before Macbeth and tells them what a great job they were doing. I think it is just meant to help add to the fact the witches really are witches.
Lane c. I think the third apparition’s tree just symbolizes either what his warning was, are that he might have been some spirit who protected or spoke for nature.
Aleea, I think scene three is basically setting up the stage for the war between Scotland and England. It gives the reasons why these three men want to overthrow Macbeth.
Zach, I think the wounds that Malcolm refers to just mean the devastation that has overcome the country since Macbeth became king.
karib: About Malcolm testing Macduff, I was also wondering how he is doing that too. I think he is testing his resolve though, or at least that is the best guess I have. I think he wanted to see if Macduff was really commited to the downfall of Macbeth, and if he would try and seize power when Malcolm tried to vacate it. But I think Macduff passed the test. For example, when Malcolm talked about his vices, Macduff didn't say "Oh, then maybe I should be king!" He said "Oh, well it looks like Scotland is in for it." And also, Malcolm pretty much got Macduff to say multiple times how much he hated Macbeth and wanted to supplant him.
I want to know why Ross was so deceptive in the beggining. Why didn't he just come out and say Macduff's family had been slaughtered if he was going to?
I want to know about Macbeth's reasoning behind the killing of Macduff's family. Has he resorted to simply rage and revenge killing, or did he do it to make a point?
JoanneH, to answer your second question, yes Malcolm is Duncan's son by birth, as is Donalbain, which I have no idea what he is doing now in all of this, but the front of your book should explain that Malcolm is Duncan's son.
Ben, I think the reasoning behind the killing of Macduff's family was that Macduff was one of Macbeth's favorite and most noble warriors. Malcolm tells Macduff that," You have loved him well". This is saying that Macduff was basically one of Macbeth's favorites. Macduff in a way has betrayed Macbeth by going to England. I also believe Macbeth had asked him to return several times and this made him furious. Then when he found out that he had fled to England with Malcolm that just put the icing on the cake, and because Macbeth has changed his entire view of killing from thinking it out to just taking action, he killed Macduff's family.
Also, for anyone confused about Malcolm testing Macduff, I think I have some information that might help. If you read carefully, you can see that Malcolm is telling Macduff that basically he is not worthy to be a king. If they overthrew Macbeth, Malcolm would be the next king. He explains that he would be even worse than Macbeth. He says that he has too many sexual desires and is greedy. Macduff responds by saying that he could look past those things and still be a great ruler. Malcolm sees this as Macduff swearing his allegiance to him and then trusts him. He concludes by saying that those things he said about himself are not true about him. Malcolm just lied to see how Macduff would respond to see if he could trust him or not.
Some things I am confused about are what side is Ross on? We find him both with Macduff and Macbeth, so who has he sided with or has he even done that? Why is he the bearer of bad news to Macduff?
Also, why would Macduff leave his wife and kids home and flee? His wife and his kids are obviously very important to him because when he finds out Macbeth has killed them, he flips and swears revenge on Macbeth. But why would he just leave them behind? Is he a coward or is he looking after them somehow?
Thanks briang. And I really agree about the testing. I thought that too.
briang: I think that ross is with Macduff and Malcolm. I don't think there is anyone that still likes Macbeth. He just brought the bad news because he was the first to find out, I think. And I don't think Macduff was a coward. I think he planned on returning as soon as possible to see his family again and overthrow Macbeth. He didn't flee, he left to join forces. I think by leaving he didn't really protect them, so he was taking a great risk. One that resulted in their death.
Just a clarifying question--When Melcom and Macduff are talking at the very beginning of scene 3, Malcom says, "Angels are bright still, though the brightest fell." Is he talking about Duncan being killed or Banquo. Or have they not even heard news that Banquo has been killed yet?
I noticed when i was taking my notes on scene two that before Macbeth enters the cave one of the witches says, "something wicked this way comes." Why does a witch who is the most wicked of all refer to a human as wicked? It seems like this is reference to Macbeth having gone so far in the whole business that he has turned evil. Is there any possibility of return to good for Macbeth? Becuase I love Star Wars I'll reference it. After being totally not a good dood at all for pretty much the entire trilogy Darth Vader has his heart changed by his son. Is there something that could change Macbeth like that?
In Scene 1, I was also confused about the witches, like Sara. Why were they chanting all of those things? Were they spells? If so, to who were they directed, or why were they saying them?
Also, I have found that a main theme for this play could be death, along with appearance vs. reality. Macbeth said that blood leads to more blood. I understand this as that once the killing starts, no one can stop it, and it is uncontrollable. I think that you can control all of your own personal actions. This makes me wonder if there is so much murder and death because it makes the killer feel more superior towards everyone else. This relates back to the whole appearance vs. reality once again, saying one acts different then who they truly are. I just want to know… what is the bug need to be something that you are not?
The only question I have for act 4 is when did Ross get to where Macduff and Malcolm are and how did he hear of the murder of Macduff's wife and son before Macduff did?
lauraf: I think that when Malcolm says, "Angels are bright still, but the brightest fell" he is talking about Macbeth, saying that he was once a hero who was trusted by all and was a great fighter in battle. He was held in great respect, but then he betrayed the trust of Duncan, murdered his friends and allies, and became a dictator, pretty much. If you read in your book, it clarifies this statement. It says that Malcolm is comparing Macbeth's fall from greatness to Satan's fall from being an angel in heaven to being the leader of hell.
Hope that helps!
Ok. A lot of my questions have been answered here. But one thing I want to know if, what are the points of having scene two and scene three?
What does it mean when the 3rd apparition says, "Be lion-mettled, proud; and take no care Who chafes, who frets, or where conspirers are: Macbeth shall never vanquish'd be until
Great Birnam wood to high Dunsinane hill Shall come against him," because that is just confusing. Does it mean an actual forest or is it a metaphor of some sort?
Also, when Lady Macduff tells her son that his father is dead, why does she tell him that? Did Ross tell her that or is she making this up?
I don't know if anyone else had difficulty with this scene but I know I did. It took several readings and rereadings for me to understand it.
MY main question was
1. Why do the witches desire to destroy MAcbeth, I mean I understand that they want to create chaos. It just seems that they are focasing all their attention on MAcbeth, I mean they prophesized about Banquo too, so why all the hype on MAcbeth?
Why does Malcolm keep on thinking that he's a good ruler and then a bad one? Or is he just lying to make Macduff believe him? Is there a trend forming with Macbeth and Malcolm now?
One more question: in Scene 1, Lines 93-97, why does Macbeth start out by saying that there is no reason for him to kill Macduff, Live on Macduff; and then ends the line by saying that he will kill him anyways, just to make sure. This relates back to my first blog response, that Macbeth cannot control his actions, and that he will just keep killing and killing.
In response to alyar's question, I think that the witches are more focused on Macbeth because he is gaining more power. Also, Banquo is dead so the prophecy about his children won't come true until Macbeth is no longer King of Scotland.
In response to kjerstenl's question, I don't believe that Malcolm is confused on what kind of king he would be. In this section, in what is considered, as Mrs. Smith said, one of the most important sections in the book, Malcolm is "testing" Macduff in a way. He needs Macduff's help, but he needs to make sure that Macduff is trustworthy first. He decides that the best way to do so is to act as though he, as heir to the throne, is an evil person. If Macduff doesn't care whether or not he would be a good king, then he is not trustworthy. If Macduff responds thus, Malcolm would be able to conclude that Macduff's true intentions are not strictly for Scotland's good, but instead that there are alterior motives behind Macduff's warhawking. If Macduff doesn't believe that Malcolm would be a good king with all of his faults, and is dismayed because of it, Macduff is a trustworthy person. He is truly interested in Scotland's well being as opposed to his own. I hope this helped to answer your questions.
Post a Comment
<< Home